Nearly half of America's renters now spend more than 30% of their income on housing. That's 22.7 million households. A record.
Twice in your lifetime, in 2008 and again in 2020, trillions of dollars appeared almost overnight. Not for you.
So who do you blame?
No wrong answers. First one that comes to mind.
Where does money come from?
Mostly, banks make it. When a bank lends, it types a number into an account. That number is new money. So says the Bank of England.
Above the banks sits a central bank. In the US, that's “the Fed.” It sets the price of borrowing. In a crisis, it creates money by the trillion.
You try.
Hold the button. You're the Fed, 2008 to 2022.
New money doesn't land everywhere at once. It enters at one spot, then moves down a line.
At the front: big banks, big funds, the government's lenders. They get it first, at yesterday's prices.
It pours into shares, bonds, property. Those prices jump first. By design: in 2010 the Fed's chairman wrote that “higher stock prices will boost consumer wealth.”
Whose wealth? Line the country up, richest first: 1,000 people.
The first 100 own 88% of all shares. The last 500 own 0.6%.
Wages come last, if the money reaches them at all. By then, the prices already have.
Look who's next to you. A nurse. A delivery rider. The woman who owns your corner café.
She owns a business and trades in a market. She's back here too.
One group gets new money first, at a price nobody else is offered. What would you call that?
And when the front of the line trips?
In 2008, it was caught: $700 billion from Congress, and $16 trillion in emergency Fed loans, counting every overnight loan.
Most was repaid. All of it was offered to the front.
At the back, nearly 7.8 million homes were foreclosed. Nobody typed money into those accounts.
The net never left. Lenders expect big banks to be rescued, so they fund them cheaper: a perk worth up to $70 billion in 2012 alone, says the IMF.
To be fair, a total collapse would have hurt the back too. But why did the rescue stop at the front?
When the café bets wrong, it closes. That's a market. This isn't.
In 2010 Bernie Sanders, a democratic socialist, and Ron Paul, a libertarian, agreed on almost nothing. Except this: open the Fed's books.
So hand the money machine to the people?
Decent instinct. The catch: whoever holds it, a line forms in front. Those nearest to power get there first, under any flag. And when it runs hot, rising prices hit the poorest hardest.
Gold was no golden age either: nationwide bank panics in 1893 and 1907, and a deeper Depression for countries that clung to it.
Nobody here is selling you a system. Or a coin. Just a better question.
You might have said: capitalism.
That word means different things to different people. If it means people owning things and trading them, the café is capitalism, and she's right next to you. If it means the powerful writing their own rules, then yes. That.
Owning and trading didn't build this line. Power and money getting too cozy did. Aim there.